# Site: watsonroach.com # URL: https://watsonroach.com # Generated: 2026-07-19 03:58:27 # Version: 1.1 # File Type: llms-full.txt # Total Pages: 53 --- ## Courtney Read selected as member of Leadership Law Class of 2019 URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/01/22/courtney-read-selected-as-member-of-leadership-law-class-of-2019/ Courtney Read has been selected as a member of the Tennessee Bar Association Leadership Law Class of 2019.  Ms. Read is one of thirty-five (35) lawyers chosen from across the state to be a part of the Leadership Law program, which is in its sixteenth year.  The Leadership Law program is designed to equip Tennessee lawyers with the vision, knowledge, and skills to serve as leaders in their profession and local communities.  The class will attend sessions across the state for the next six months focusing on topics such as issues facing the courts and policymaking in state government. --- ## Dan R. Pilkington URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/dan-r-pilkington/ #### Member # Dan R. Pilkington Email Dan Dan Pilkington has almost 20 years of experience representing individuals, businesses, and governmental entities in civil litigation matters. His areas of practice include insurance defense, civil rights, discrimination, wrongful discharge, contract disputes, land use and zoning, and personal injury. He is also experienced in governmental tort law, environmental law, and cannabis law. He focuses his practice on defending law enforcement in claims of false arrest and excessive force. He also devotes a significant amount of his practice to the defense of physicians and providers in medical malpractice cases. Mr. Pilkington is an experienced trial litigator who handles complex litigation in both state and federal courts. He frequently represents clients before the Tennessee Court of Appeals and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Whenever possible, he also counsels clients on litigation avoidance strategies. He is a native of East Tennessee. He, along with his wife, two children, and two dogs, lives on their farm in East Knox County. ### Awards + Recognition • AV® Preeminent Peer Review Rated by Martindale-Hubbell ### Memberships + Associations • Knoxville Bar Association • Tennessee Bar Association ### Education • J.D., University of Tennessee College of Law, Knoxville, TN, 2005 • B.B.A, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, TN, 2002 ### Admissions • Tennessee, 2005 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 2006 • United States District Court, Middle District of Tennessee, 2015 • United States Bankruptcy Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 2006 • United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 2008 ## Representative cases ##### Francis v. City of Red Bank (2022) Obtained summary judgement and dismissal of individual officer accused of excessive force in deadly use of force case. Decision was affirmed by the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. ##### Whiting v. City of Athens (2022) Secured swift unanimous jury verdict following multi-day trial before Chief Judge of the Federal District Court for the Eastern District of Tennessee in first amendment case. ##### Chuck's Package Store v. City of Morristown (2018) Prevailed in the Tennessee Supreme Court securing reversal of intermediate appellate court and trial court in high value municipal taxation case. ##### Schmitt v. City of East Ridge (2019) Obtained summary judgment in United States District Court in highly charged law enforcement deadly use of force matter. ##### LaFollette v. City of Gatlinburg (2012) United States District Court granted summary judgment in employment discrimination matter involving ADA and age discrimination claims. --- ## Reid Alan Spaulding URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/reid-alan-spaulding/ #### Member # Reid A. Spaulding Email Reid Reid Spaulding has 20 years of experience and concentrates his practice on civil litigation defense. Mr. Spaulding regularly defends employers in employment discrimination matters before Tennessee and federal courts and administrative agencies. He has significant experience in defending Tennessee police officers against Section 1983 claims, including allegations of false arrest, excessive force, and failure to intervene. Mr. Spaulding routinely defends governmental entities and their employees in federal and state courts across Tennessee. Prior to joining the firm, Mr. Spaulding practiced law in the State of Illinois for three years. During this time, he gained experience and perspective representing plaintiffs in personal injury and workers’ compensation matters. ### Memberships • Knoxville Bar Association • American Bar Association • Tennessee Bar Association • American Inns of Court, Barrister ### Education • J.D., University of Illinois College of Law, Champaign, IL, 2001 • B.A., Political Science, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN, 1995 • B.A., Economics, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN, 1995 ### Admissions • Illinois, 2001 • Tennessee, 2004 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 2005 • United States District Court, Middle District of Tennessee, 2007 • United States District Court, Western District of Tennessee, 2012 • United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 2006 • Supreme Court of the United States, 2021 ## Representative cases ##### Weinert v. City of Sevierville (2019) Prevailed in appellate court after grant of summary judgment in employment discrimination matter arising out of resignation of police officer that dealt with novel issues of constructive discharge. ##### Thomas v. City of Madisonville (2013) Obtained favorable verdict in United States District Court after two day jury trial in matter involving procurement of a search warrant by a law enforcement officer. ##### Doherty v. City of Maryville (2011) Sixth Circuit reversed and vacated verdict for plaintiffs at trial in labor relations matter brought by members of a local firefighters’ union. ##### Spears v. Ruth (2009) Obtained reversal of denial of qualified immunity to law enforcement officer in case involving an arrestee who died from a drug overdose while in custody. --- ## Practice Areas URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/ # Experienced litigators Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. ## Commercial General Liability Watson Roach defends commercial, municipal and insurance clients in premises and operational liability claims. View Practice ## Cybersecurity As data management and protection becomes an essential part of daily business, Watson Roach is responding with capabilities in a cybersecurity practice. View Practice ## Employment Practices Liability The employment attorneys at Watson Roach defend Tennessee employers in a full range of employment disputes. View Practice ## Governmental Entity Defense Cities, counties, law enforcement agencies, boards of education, and other municipal agencies are aggressively defended. View Practice ## Professional Liability Watson Roach is experienced in defending real estate agents, surveyors and related professionals in errors and omissions (E&O) disputes ranging from simple negligence to complex claims for violations of federal or state statutes. View Practice ## Medical Malpractice The firm has decades of experience in medical malpractice defense. Hospitals, health systems, physicians, surgeons, and practice groups are represented in claims ranging from misdiagnosis to failure to treat and surgical errors. View Practice ## Workers’ Compensation Tennessee employers, insurers and third party administrators are defended in workers’ compensation claims involving on-the-job or psychological injury, infectious or occupational diseases, heart attacks, death claims, and COVID-19 illnesses. View Practice ## Civil Litigation Watson Roach defends businesses, individuals, employers, and governmental entities in a variety of civil litigation matters in state and federal court. View Practice ## Insurance Defense Watson Roach attorneys work regularly with various insurance companies across the Southeast in the investigation and defense of insurance claims. View Practice --- ## Hanson Tipton Participates in Investiture Ceremony of United States District Judge Charles E. Atchley, Jr. URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/08/24/hanson-tipton-participates-in-investiture-ceremony-of-united-states-district-judge-charles-e-atchley-jr/ On Friday, August 20, 2021, firm member Hanson R. Tipton, who serves as Immediate Past President of the Knoxville Bar Association, was one of the presenters for the formal investiture ceremony of United States District Judge for the Eastern District of Tennessee Charles E. Atchley, Jr. Judge Atchley was nominated last year by the President, confirmed by the Senate, and received his judicial commission on December 22, 2020. Mr. Tipton participated in the ceremony on behalf of the Knoxville Bar Association and presented a judicial robe to Judge Atchley. Speakers at the investiture included Chief United States District Judge Travis R. McDonough, former Senator Lamar Alexander, Knoxville Attorney Wade Davies, and former United States Attorney Doug Overbey. --- ## Contact URL: https://watsonroach.com/contact/ 865.637.1700 info@watsonroach.com Watson, Roach, Batson & Lauderback 900 South Gay Street Knoxville, TN 37902 Monday 8:00AM – 5:00PM Tuesday 8:00AM – 5:00PM Wednesday 8:00AM – 5:00PM Thursday 8:00AM – 5:00PM Friday 8:00AM – 5:00PM Saturday Closed Sunday Closed ## How can our attorneys help you today? While we are always interested in hearing from existing clients, potential clients, and visitors to our website, we cannot accept representation on a new matter from either existing or new clients until we know we do not have a conflict of interest that would prevent us from doing so. Therefore, please do not send us information about any new matter that may involve potential legal representation until we have confirmed a conflict of interest does not exist and we have expressly agreed to representation. Unless you are already a client of Watson, Roach, Batson & Lauderback P. L. C., your e-mail may not be treated as privileged or confidential. If you are a client and communicate with us via e-mail, please remember e-mail is not fully secure. Disclaimer: The information contained in the Watson, Roach, Batson & Lauderback, P.L.C. website is provided for informational purposes only and is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. Transmission of this site and the use and submission of information to the site do not create an attorney-client relationship and such information will not be considered privileged. The information contained herein is general and may not reflect current legal developments, verdicts or settlements and should not be relied upon. The material in this site may be considered advertising. The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements. Before you decide, ask us to send you free written information about our qualifications and experience. --- ## Yasmine Ly Parker URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/yasmine-ly-parker/ #### Associate # Yasmine Ly Parker Email Yasmine Yasmine Ly Parker is an associate attorney at Watson, Roach, Batson & Lauderback, P.L.C. Born and raised in Memphis, TN, Yasmine moved to Knoxville to attend the University of Tennessee where she earned her bachelor’s degree and J.D. Yasmine graduated law school with a concentration in Advocacy and Dispute Resolution, where she honed her advocacy skills through hands-on experience in the Expungement Clinic and as a student attorney in the Advocacy Clinic. She also served as a Research Editor for the Tennessee Journal of Race, Gender and Social Justice . In her free time, Yasmine enjoys cooking new recipes, exploring new places, and cheering on the Vols. ### Memberships • Knoxville Bar Association • Tennessee Bar Association ### Education • J.D., University of Tennessee College of Law, Knoxville, TN, 2023 • B.A., magna cum laude, Political Science and Sociology, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN, 2019 ### Admissions • Tennessee, 2024 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 2024 --- ## Our Firm URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-firm/ # Serving Knoxville since 1983 Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Attorneys with a respected legacy of consistent success Since its inception, Watson, Roach, Batson & Lauderback, P.L.C., has earned recognition as one of the most successful and accomplished litigation firms not only in Knoxville and Tennessee, but also throughout the Southeast. Watson Roach was formed in 1983 by founding partner Robert H. Watson, Jr. Mr. Watson built the firm with the help of many other talented and dedicated attorneys and members of staff, and the firm quickly developed a reputation for excellence in civil litigation, particularly in the representation of local governmental entities and in the representation of medical professionals in health care liability matters. Jon G. Roach and John T. Batson, Jr. joined the firm in 1990. The Firm has changed names throughout the years, but Mr. Watson’s legacy of principled, vigorous and aggressive defense of litigation matters remains among the Firm’s guiding precepts. Watson Roach attorneys aim to work hard and be better prepared than their adversary, and to put their experience to work for their clients. At Watson Roach, every case is aggressively defended from its onset. The Firm has a demanding motion and discovery practice that is tailored to meet the varied needs of its clients. While many defense firms lean on the practice of delay and settle, Watson Roach relies on a skilled defense strategy. The Firm sets the tone for the lawsuit by taking action and putting its clients in the decisive posture. Watson Roach attorneys regularly work with insurance and risk management companies and professionals. Watson Roach is familiar with the considerations and factors that influence litigation decisionmaking from a claims professional’s perspective, and Firm attorneys work in tandem with those professionals in managing litigation. Watson Roach attorneys also regularly handle coverage and first party litigation. Civil litigation is stressful for all parties involved, but particularly for individuals or entities accused of misconduct. Watson Roach attorneys strive to keep individual and corporate clients informed of and involved in the litigation process, and take as much of the burden of litigation as possible off the shoulders of the client. When the stakes are high as they always are when a legal dispute is heading to court, a lawyer’s or law firm’s experience can make all the difference. Watson Roach’s tailored trial strategies, team approach, combined with the requisite knowledge, skill, loyalty, creativity, and perseverance are the winning edge for the Firm’s clients. #### Experienced Attorneys ## Discover our decades of experience in law. Meet Our Attorneys #### Get Quoted Today ## Ready to discuss your case with us? Contact Us Today #### Our Practice Areas ## Experienced leaders in our areas of practice • Commercial General Liability • Cybersecurity • Employment Practices Liability • Governmental Entity Defense • Professional Liability • Medical Malpractice • Worker’s Compensation • Civil Litigation • Insurance Defense View Practice Areas --- ## Employment Practices Liability URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/employment-practice-liability/ # Employment Practices Liability Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Trusted experts in workplace disputes and employment litigation Watson Roach advises and assists employers in policies and procedures, litigation avoidance, and workplace investigations. The employment attorneys at Watson Roach are prepared to defend Tennessee employers in a full range of employment disputes and litigation including: • Discrimination claims  • Family and medical leave • Negligent hiring, retention, or supervision • Wage and hour disputes • Whistleblower and retaliation claims • Workplace investigations  • Wrongful discharge Employers are represented in state and federal courts as well as before administrative agencies. • Equal Employment Opportunity Commission • Tennessee Human Rights Commission --- ## Firm News URL: https://watsonroach.com/firm-news/ # Stay updated on our firm news Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Stay up to date on all legal and professional developments at Watson Roach --- ## Medical Malpractice URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/medical-malpractice/ # Medical Malpractice Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Advocating for medical and health care professionals The firm has decades of experience in medical malpractice defense. Hospitals, health systems, physicians, surgeons, and practice groups are represented in claims ranging from misdiagnosis to failure to treat and surgical errors. The firm works collaboratively with health care professionals to vigorously investigate and defend claims. Watson Roach also represents health care professionals before licensing boards and regulatory agencies. --- ## Brian Bibb Authors Article on Employment Law in Knoxville Business Journal URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/09/23/brian-bibb-authors-article-on-employment-law-in-knoxville-business-journal/ Member Brian R. Bibb submitted an article on employment law as a contributing guest columnist in the August edition of the Knoxville News Sentinel, Knoxville Business Journal. Mr. Bibb’s article focused on employee evaluations and advises employers on how to appropriately handle performance evaluations with an eye toward being prepared for any potential lawsuits or employment discrimination investigations. Mr. Bibb, along with several other members of the firm, regularly advises employers on employment law and employment discrimination matters and defends employment law and regulatory matters before state and federal administrative bodies and in state and federal court. Read Mr. Bibb’s article --- ## Hanson R. Tipton Sworn In as President of Knoxville Bar Association URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/01/21/hanson-r-tipton-sworn-in-as-president-of-knoxville-bar-association/ Hanson R. Tipton was sworn in as President of the Knoxville Bar Association at the Knoxville Bar Association Annual Meeting and Elections on December 13, 2019. The KBA serves nearly 2,000 members with an eighteen-member Board of Governors. All KBA policies and programs are either developed or overseen by the bar's Board of Governors. The Executive Committee (Officers of the Knoxville Bar Association) consists of the President, the President-Elect, the Secretary, the Treasurer, and the Immediate Past President. Mr. Tipton served as President-Elect for the 2019 Bar year. He has served on and chaired numerous committees and boards in the Knoxville and Tennessee Bar Associations. He won the 2014 KBA President’s Award in recognition of outstanding performance and dedicated service on behalf of the Knoxville Bar Association. In his introductory remarks at the Annual Meeting, Mr. Tipton thanked the members for their continued committed service to the KBA and the people of our community in need of legal services. He discussed his plans for 2020, including a Habitat for Humanity house build, celebration of the centennial of women’s suffrage in the United States, and a focus on servant leadership. Mr. Tipton encouraged members to take advantage of the many resources and service opportunities offered by the KBA. --- ## Watson Roach Batson & Lauderback P.L.C. Recently Recognized as a 2023 “Best Law Firm” URL: https://watsonroach.com/2022/12/02/watson-roach-batson-lauderback-p-l-c-was-recently-recognized-as-a-2023-best-law-firm/ Watson Roach Batson & Lauderback P.L.C. was recently recognized as a 2023 “Best Law Firm” by U.S. News-Best Lawyers© in the practice area of Medical Malpractice-Defendants. The criteria to be selected as a “Best Law Firm” includes client feedback, peer review, a Law Firm Leaders survey, and a firm survey. --- ## Worker's Compensation URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/workers-compensation/ # Workers' Compensation Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Experienced guidance for Tennessee employers and insurers Tennessee employers, insurers and third party administrators are defended in workers’ compensation claims involving on-the-job or psychological injury, infectious or occupational diseases, heart attacks, death claims, and COVID-19 illnesses. The firm represents clients in the Mediation Program and Benefit Review Conferences before the Tennessee Department of Labor and Workforce Development, Division of Workers’ Compensation (TDOL). The firm represents clients in trial and appeals before the Tennessee Workers' Compensation Court of Claims. --- ## Brian R. Bibb URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/brian-r-bibb/ #### Member # Brian R. Bibb Email Brian Brian Bibb has 12 years of litigation experience and devotes the majority of his practice to complex litigation, with an emphasis on the defense of governmental entities. Mr. Bibb regularly defends employers in employment discrimination matters and law enforcement officers in civil rights litigation. Mr. Bibb has engaged in extensive appellate practice before the Tennessee and federal courts of appeal, having been counsel in 25 favorable appellate decisions since 2013, including 4 matters before the Tennessee Supreme Court. While in law school, Mr. Bibb served as an Articles Editor for the Tennessee Law Review and as a teaching assistant for the college's legal writing course. Mr. Bibb is a native of Knoxville, Tennessee. Outside of the office, he is an avid reader, particularly of biographies and American history. He lives in Oak Ridge with his wife and three children. ### Awards + Recognitions • Outstanding Graduate of the UT College of Law Class of 2012 • Order of the Coif • Chancellor’s Citation for Extraordinary Professional Promise ### Memberships + Associations • Federal Bar Association - Knoxville Chapter • Knoxville Bar Association • Tennessee Bar Association ### Education • J.D., summa cum laude , University of Tennessee College of Law, Knoxville, TN, 2012 • B.A., summa cum laude , History, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN, 2009 ### Admissions • Tennessee, 2012 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 2013 • United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 2013 • United States District Court, Middle District of Tennessee, 2021 • Supreme Court of the United States, 2021 ## Representative cases ##### Condrone v. City of Maryville (2017) Obtained defense verdict after seven day jury trial in United States District Court in employment discrimination matter alleging sexual harassment and retaliatory discharge. ##### Chuck's Package Store v. City of Morristown (2018) Prevailed in the Tennessee Supreme Court securing reversal of intermediate appellate court and trial court in high value municipal taxation case. ##### Young v. City of LaFollette (2015) Secured favorable decision in Tennessee Supreme Court, setting precedent on the availability of a jury trial on Tennessee state law whistleblower claims brought in circuit courts. ##### Mathis v. City of Red Bank (2016) Sixth Circuit affirmed grant of summary judgment below in matter involving employment discrimination and ADA claims against an employer by a public works employee. --- ## Emily Taylor Provides Training on Cybersecurity and Data Breach Liability URL: https://watsonroach.com/2022/10/06/emily-taylor-provides-training-on-cybersecurity-and-data-breach-liability/ Member Emily Taylor recently conducted a training seminar for claims handling professionals regarding cybersecurity and data breach liability claims for public entities in Tennessee. Ms. Taylor explained the procedure for coordinating responses with IT professionals and claims personnel to data breach incidents, including ransomware and malware attacks. Ms. Taylor also reviewed the requirements of Tennessee’s data breach notification statute, including Tenn. Code Ann. § 47-18-2107, and how public entities and other businesses should respond to a data breach incident. Data breach claims, and cyber-liability policies, are an increasingly common reality for both public and private entities, and Watson Roach offers experience and expertise in handling cyber-liability claims and coordinating responses to data breach and ransomware incidents. --- ## Benj Lauderback and Brian Bibb Present Training Seminar for Law Enforcement Officers URL: https://watsonroach.com/2022/07/14/benj-lauderback-and-brian-bibb-present-training-seminar-for-law-enforcement-officers/ Benj Lauderback and Brian Bibb presented a continuing education training at the 2022 command staff retreat and training for the City of Morristown Police Department in Gatlinburg, Tennessee. Mr. Lauderback and Mr. Bibb provided an update on recent cases and training for law enforcement use of force, litigation avoidance, litigation process, and best practices. The training was certified by the Tennessee Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission (P.O.S.T.), which serves as the primary regulatory body for Tennessee law enforcement. --- ## Hanson R. Tipton Elected President-Elect of Knoxville Bar Association URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/01/22/hanson-r-tipton-elected-president-elect-of-knoxville-bar-association/ Hanson R. Tipton was elected President-Elect of the Knoxville Bar Association at the Knoxville Bar Association Annual Meeting and Elections on December 14, 2018.  The KBA serves nearly 2,000 members with an eighteen-member Board of Governors.  All KBA policies and programs are either developed or overseen by the bar's Board of Governors.  The Executive Committee (Officers of the Knoxville Bar Association) consists of the President, the President-Elect, the Secretary, the Treasurer, and the Immediate Past President.  Mr. Tipton served as Treasurer for the 2018 Bar year and also serves as a Co-Chairman of the KBA Judicial Committee. --- ## Cybersecurity URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/cybersecurity/ # Cybersecurity Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Working to stay on the cutting edge of cyber liability As data management and protection becomes an essential part of daily business, Watson Roach is responding with capabilities in a cybersecurity practice. When a data breach or ransomware attack occurs, the firm is available to launch an immediate investigation with IT forensic experts. The firm works with the targeted entity to initiate reporting obligations to relevant state and federal agencies, law enforcement, consumer reporting agencies, and affected individuals. --- ## Several Watson Roach Attorneys Recognized as Top Lawyers in Their Practice Areas URL: https://watsonroach.com/2022/08/29/several-watson-roach-attorneys-recognized-as-top-lawyers-in-their-practice-areas/ Members Hanson Tipton and Courtney Read were recognized again this year in the annual “Best Lawyers in America” list in the area of medical malpractice law – defendants. Best Lawyers goes through a vetted, peer-reviewed process to identify practice leaders throughout this region and around the country. Member John Batson was also recognized as a Top Attorney in Knoxville’s Cityview Magazine in the area of administrative law. Cityview Magazine conducts an annual survey of local bar members and identifies leaders within the Knoxville legal community. Mr. Batson has been recognized several times in past years by Cityview. --- ## Hanson R. Tipton URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/hanson-r-tipton/ #### Member # Hanson R. Tipton Email Hanson Hanson Tipton has over 20 years of experience, and practices in the areas of health care liability, civil defense litigation, government tort law, workers’ compensation, and insurance defense. Mr. Tipton is a natural leader who has held many voluntary and elected leadership positions with the Tennessee Bar Association and the Knoxville Bar Association. He is a graduate of the Tennessee Bar Association's Leadership Law Class of 2008. In 2020, he served as President of the Knoxville Bar Association, which includes more than 2,000 members and an 18 member Board of Governors. He won the 2014 KBA President’s Award in recognition of outstanding performance and dedicated service on behalf of the Knoxville Bar Association. He also currently serves on the Alumni Council for the University of Tennessee College of Law. Mr. Tipton served as a law clerk for Senior Judge John K. Byers for almost two years following law school. Mr. Tipton was born and raised in Knoxville and is a lifelong fan of University of Tennessee athletics. He enjoys traveling to and attending concerts and athletic events across the South and beyond. ### Awards + Recognitions • AV® Preeminent Peer Review Rated by Martindale-Hubbell ### Memberships + Associations • Tennessee Bar Association • Continuing Legal Education Committee, Past Member • Young Lawyers Division Publications Committee, Past Chair • American Bar Association • Knoxville Bar Association, President 2020, Board of Governors, 2013 to 2015 and 2016 to 2021 • Knoxville Bar Foundation, Fellows, 2017 to Present • University of Tennessee College of Law Alumni Council, 2021 to Present ### Education • J.D., University of Tennessee College of Law, Knoxville, TN, 2002 • B.S., Psychology, Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL, 1996 ### Admissions • Tennessee, 2002 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 2004 • United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 2004 ## Representative cases ##### Health Care Liability Matter Obtained defense verdict after five day jury trial in health care liability matter involving alleged failure to timely diagnose a lung tumor. ##### Health Care Liability Matter Obtained defense verdict after ten day jury trial in health care liability matter arising out of the death of a young woman who developed myocarditis while hospitalized. ##### Dennis v. Smith (2015) Prevailed on appeal after motion to dismiss filed under Tennessee’s Health Care Liability Act was granted below. ##### Bohanan v. City of Knoxville (2004) Obtained favorable opinion in the Tennessee Supreme Court reversing lower court in workers’ compensation hypertension case. --- ## Emily C. Taylor URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/emily-c-taylor/ #### Member # Emily C. Taylor Email Emily Emily Taylor has 16 years of experience in civil litigation and appeals, employment litigation defense, insurance defense, and governmental tort matters. Ms. Taylor also handles cybersecurity and data breach response matters for entities across the state of Tennessee. Ms. Taylor is a faculty member for the Tennessee Bar Association’s continuing education program, where she has taught the courses “Tort and Insurance: TN Governmental Tort Liability Act,” and “Tort and Insurance Forum 2017.” While in law school, she earned the Certificate of Academic Excellence for Pretrial Litigation and Trial Practice and had an article published in Transactions: The Tennessee Journal of Business Law. She was recognized as a Top Collegiate Scholar in college. Ms. Taylor and her husband enjoy spending time on the lake, traveling (particularly to National Parks), and hiking in Smoky Mountains. ### Memberships + Associations • Knoxville Bar Association • Tennessee Bar Association, Leadership Law Class of 2016 • Chi Omega, Member of House Corporation • Phi Alpha Delta • Wesley House – Board of Directors, Past President • Sorority Village Association, Treasurer ### Education • J.D., cum laude , University of Tennessee College of Law, Knoxville, TN, 2008 • B.S., summa cum laude, Retail and Consumer Science, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN, 2005 ### Admissions • Tennessee, 2008 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 2008 • United States District Court, Middle District of Tennessee, 2011 • United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 2013 ## Representative cases ##### Brumley v. City of Cleveland (2019) Obtained defense verdict after three day bench trial in employment discrimination matter involving whistleblower and retaliation claims. ##### Meadows v. Maryville City School System (2012) Obtained favorable verdict after eight day jury trial in claim arising out of the alleged sexual assault of a student with physical and mental disabilities by another student while on a school bus. ##### SWard v. Knox Cty. Bd. of Educ. (2015) Obtained decision in the Sixth Circuit affirming grant of summary judgment in trademark and copyright challenge to the Knox County Schools “Coupon Book” fundraiser program. ##### Young v. City of LaFollette (2015) Secured favorable decision in Tennessee Supreme Court, setting precedent on the availability of a jury trial on Tennessee state law whistleblower claims brought in circuit courts. --- ## Brian Bibb Presents Training Seminar for Local Law Enforcement and First Responders URL: https://watsonroach.com/2022/04/12/brian-bibb-presents-training-seminar-for-local-law-enforcement-and-first-responders/ Brian R. Bibb recently presented a training seminar on civil liability and the litigation process to law enforcement officers, first responders and mental health professionals as part of Crisis Intervention (CIT) training. “CIT training is a specialized, 40-hour program for law enforcement officers, and in conjunction with robust community partnerships, the goal is to improve outcomes of encounters with people living with behavioral health challenges. In the 30 plus years since it was created, the CIT model has spread across the nation and even been replicated around the world. … With the nation's focus on policing practices, mental health, and improving outcomes for everyone involved, CIT has never been more important or more relevant.” ( https://www.tn.gov/behavioral-health/cit.html ) Mr. Bibb trained attendees on law enforcement response to crisis situations as well as litigation avoidance strategies. The training was certified by the Tennessee Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission (P.O.S.T.), which serves as the primary regulatory body for Tennessee law enforcement. --- ## Three Watson Roach Attorneys Admitted in Middle District Federal Court URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/08/02/three-watson-roach-attorneys-admitted-in-middle-district-federal-court/ Watson Roach attorneys Courtney Read, Brian Bibb and Tippany Ward all were granted admission into the United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee this year in ceremonies conducted in Nashville by United States District Judge William L. Campbell, Jr. Eight Watson Roach attorneys are admitted to practice in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee, which covers the middle part of the state with courthouses in Nashville, Columbia and Cookeville. --- ## Commercial General Liability URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/commercial-general-liability/ # Commercial General Liability Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Innovative and effective litigators Watson Roach defends commercial, municipal and insurance clients in premises and operational liability claims. The firm is experienced in disputes alleging bodily injury, automobile liability and coverage, property damage, advertising injury, and personal injury to a third party for which a company is liable. Litigation avoidance remains a priority, and the firm strives to resolve claims through mediation, arbitration or negotiated settlement whenever possible. When alternative dispute resolution techniques are not sufficient to resolve a claim, the firm works aggressively to prepare for trial. --- ## Dan R. Pilkington presents continuing legal education seminar URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/01/22/dan-r-pilkington-presents-continuing-legal-education-seminar/ Member Dan R. Pilkington presented a continued education program on September 25, 2019 to educate other lawyers on new and revised laws legalizing hemp, cbd and cannabis products. The program was part of the Knoxville Bar Association’s Summer Fun Series and took place at Bluhen Botanicals in downtown Knoxville. Video of the program is available on demand through the Knoxville Bar Association’s website. --- ## Dan Pilkington presents training seminar for East Tennessee law enforcement URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/05/18/dan-pilkington-presents-training-seminar-for-east-tennessee-law-enforcement/ Dan Pilkington Dan R. Pilkington assisted local law enforcement officers by providing training on litigation of constitutional claims both in the civil and criminal arenas. The training included a discussion of recent criminal prosecutions of law enforcement including the Derek Chauvin trial. In addition, Mr. Pilkington provided tips and best practices for avoiding litigation. The training was certified by Tennessee Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission (P.O.S.T.), which serves as the primary regulatory body for Tennessee law enforcement. --- ## Multiple Watson Roach Attorneys Recognized as Top Lawyers by Their Peers URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/11/23/multiple-watson-roach-attorneys-recognized-as-top-lawyers-by-their-peers/ Member John Batson was recognized as a Top Attorney in Knoxville’s Cityview Magazine in the area of administrative law. Cityview Magazine conducts an annual survey of local bar members and identifies leaders within the Knoxville legal community. Mr. Batson has been recognized several times in past years by Cityview. Members Hanson Tipton and Courtney Read were also recognized in the annual “Best Lawyers in America” list in the area of medical malpractice law - defendants. Best Lawyers goes through a vetted, peer-reviewed process to identify practice leaders throughout this region and around the country. --- ## Brian R. Bibb becomes Member of Firm URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/01/22/brian-r-bibb-becomes-member-of-firm/ Brian R. Bibb became a member of Watson, Roach, Batson, Rowell & Lauderback, P.L.C. effective January 1, 2019.  Mr. Bibb has been with the firm since 2012, and practices in the areas of civil litigation, appellate practice, governmental entity defense, civil rights and employment discrimination. --- ## Courtney E. Read URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/courtney-e-read/ #### Member # Courtney E. Read Email Courtney Courtney Read has 14 years of civil litigation experience, including governmental tort law litigation, employment law, healthcare liability defense, and real estate broker defense. Ms. Read focuses her practice on the defense of real estate professionals in errors and omissions litigation, the defense of doctors and other medical professionals, and the defense of governmental entities. While in law school at Wake Forest University, Ms. Read served as the Student Bar Association President, earned a certificate of academic excellence in the Innocence and Justice Clinic, and served on the recruitment committee for new Wake Forest Law faculty. Ms. Read and her husband, Josh, can be found running, snow skiing, wake boarding, and traveling when not otherwise working. ### Memberships + Associations • Tennessee Bar Association, Graduate, Leadership Law Class of 2019 • Tennessee Board of Law Examiners Investigatory Committee Interviewer • Knoxville Bar Association, Functions Committee, Current Co-Chair • East Tennessee Lawyers Association for Women, Membership Chair • Nucleus Knoxville, a forum for young professionals, Past President • Knoxville Bar Foundation, Fellow, 2023 • Sertoma My Life Board, 2021 to present • Delta Delta Delta ### Education • J.D., Wake Forest University School of Law, Winston-Salem, NC, 2010 • B.A., cum laude, Political Science, Wake Forest University, Winston-Salem, NC, 2007 ### Admissions • Tennessee, 2010 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 2011 • United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 2015 • United States District Court, Middle District of Tennessee, 2021 • Supreme Court of the United States, 2022 ## Representative cases ##### Health Care Liability Matter Obtained defense verdict after five day jury trial in health care liability matter involving alleged failure to timely diagnose a lung tumor. ##### Dennis v. Smith (2015) Prevailed on appeal after motion to dismiss filed under Tennessee’s Health Care Liability Act was granted below. ##### Estate of Quinn ex rel. Quinn v. Henderson (2014) Secured decision affirming grant of summary judgment in wrongful death case arising out of emergency response to an intentionally set fire. ##### Haynes v. Lunsford (2017) Court of Appeals affirmed grant of summary judgment below in errors and omission case involving defense of a real estate agent after sale of a cabin. --- ## Multiple Watson Roach Lawyers selected as Top Attorneys URL: https://watsonroach.com/2024/09/18/multiple-watson-roach-lawyers-selected-as-top-attorneys/ Members John Batson, Benjamin Lauderback and Courtney Read were recognized as Top Attorneys in Knoxville’s Cityview Magazine. Mr. Batson was recognized in Administrative Law and Workers Compensation Defense. Mr. Lauderback was recognized in Constitutional Law/Civil Rights. Ms. Read was recognized in Professional Malpractice – Defense. Cityview Magazine conducts an annual survey of local bar members and identifies leaders within the Knoxville legal community. --- ## Brian Bibb Provides Training for Area Law Enforcement and First Responders URL: https://watsonroach.com/2023/02/28/brian-bibb-provides-training-for-area-law-enforcement-and-first-responders/ Brian R. Bibb recently presented a training seminar on civil liability and the litigation process to law enforcement officers, first responders and mental health professionals organized by the Morristown Police Department as part of Crisis Intervention (CIT) training. “CIT training is a specialized, 40-hour program for law enforcement officers, and in conjunction with robust community partnerships, the goal is to improve outcomes of encounters with people living with behavioral health challenges. In the 30 plus years since it was created, the CIT model has spread across the nation and even been replicated around the world. … With the nation's focus on policing practices, mental health, and improving outcomes for everyone involved, CIT has never been more important or more relevant.” ( https://www.tn.gov/behavioral-health/cit.html ). Mr. Bibb trained attendees on law enforcement response to crisis situations as well as litigation avoidance strategies. The training was certified by the Tennessee Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission (P.O.S.T.), which serves as the primary regulatory body for Tennessee law enforcement. --- ## Civil Litigation URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/civil-litigation/ # Civil Litigation Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Experienced and effective litigators Watson Roach defends businesses, individuals, employers, and governmental entities in a variety of civil litigation matters in state and federal court. The firm’s practice is diverse, but includes the defense of automobile liability, premises liability and operational liability claims. The firm also maintains a land use and zoning litigation practice. The attorneys at Watson Roach take a pragmatic approach to litigation defense, but are always prepared to defend matters through trial and appeal if necessary. Watson Roach has a robust motion practice, with a proven track record of success. Attorneys at Watson Roach regularly appear in state and federal courts throughout Middle and East Tennessee, and also maintain a busy appellate practice in the Tennessee and federal courts of appeal. --- ## Our Attorneys URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/ # Serving Knoxville since 1983 Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Our Attorneys ## East Tennessee Attorneys Whether you need representation in a state, federal or appellate court or before an administrative agency, Watson Roach has the skill, experience, and legal knowledge to get you the result you need. ### John T. Batson, Jr. Member ### Benjamin K. Lauderback Member ### Hanson R. Tipton Member ### Reid A. Spaulding Member ### Dan R. Pilkington Member ### Emily C. Taylor Member ### Courtney E. Read Member ### Brian R. Bibb Member ### Yasmine Ly Parker Associate ### Elise M. DeNicola Associate ### Jon G. Roach Of Counsel ### Robert H. Watson, Jr. Attorney (1945-2014) --- ## Multiple Watson Roach Lawyers selected as Best Lawyers and Top Attorneys URL: https://watsonroach.com/2023/08/24/multiple-watson-roach-lawyers-selected-as-best-lawyers-and-top-attorneys/ Members Hanson Tipton and Courtney Read were recognized again this year in the annual “Best Lawyers in America” list in the area of Medical Malpractice Law – Defendants. Member Courtney Read was also recognized in Litigation – Real Estate as a “Best Lawyer.” Best Lawyers goes through a vetted, peer-reviewed process to identify practice leaders throughout this region and around the country. Members John Batson, Benjamin Lauderback and Hanson Tipton were also recognized as Top Attorneys in Knoxville’s Cityview Magazine. Mr. Batson was recognized in Administrative Law. Mr. Lauderback was recognized in Constitutional Law/Civil Rights. Mr. Tipton was recognized in Medical Malpractice – Defense and Workers Compensation Defense.  Cityview Magazine conducts an annual survey of local bar members and identifies leaders within the Knoxville legal community. Mr. Batson has been recognized several times in past years by Cityview. --- ## Home URL: https://watsonroach.com/ # Experienced litigators, advocates and counselors Watson Roach has earned recognition as one of the most successful and accomplished litigation firms in the Southeast. #### Our firm ## A history of success. We leverage our skill and experience in obtaining the best results for our clients in complex and often highly-charged civil litigation matters. Our Firm's History ### Commercial General Liability ### Cybersecurity ### Employment Practices Liability ### Governmental Entity Defense ### Professional Liability ### Medical Malpractice ### Worker's Compensation ### Civil Litigation ### Insurance Defense #### Our practice areas ## 195 years of collective experience. At Watson Roach, we defend insurance companies, risk management agencies, individuals, small and large corporations, and governmental entities. View Practice Areas #### Firm News ## Stay up to date with the latest about our firm. View All Posts --- ## John T. Batson, Jr. URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/john-t-batson-jr/ #### Member # John T. Batson, Jr. Email John John Batson has over 40 years of experience in defending Tennessee businesses, governmental agencies, and insurance carriers before state and federal courts and in mediation. Employment law is an important part of his practice. Mr. Batson represents employers in workers' compensation, employment discrimination, and wage and hour claims. Mr. Batson also maintains an active governmental law practice. He defends municipalities and agencies in personal injury and property damage lawsuits, land use and zoning litigation, state and local taxation, and school merger disputes. His commercial law practice includes debtor-creditor and creditor bankruptcy matters. Prior to joining the firm, Mr. Batson served as Deputy Law Director for the City of Knoxville from 1986 to 1990 and as Assistant City Attorney from 1984 to 1986. He also held the position of Knox County Delinquent Tax Attorney from 1990 to 1994. ### Education • J.D., Memphis State University Cecil C. Humphreys School of Law, Memphis, TN, 1982 • B.A., with honors, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN, 1976 -- Member, Phi Sigma Alpha Honor Fraternity ### Admissions • Tennessee, 1982 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 1984 • United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 1988 ## Representative cases • Nall v. City of Oak Ridge, 2014 WL 5099588 (October 10, 2014) (governmental law - personnel policies involving employee pay and benefits) • Citizens for Safety and Clean Air, et al. v. City of Clinton, Tennessee, Clinton Municipal Planning Commission and Rogers Group, Inc., 434 S.W.3d 122 (Tenn. Ct. App. 2013) (perm. app. denied March 5, 2014) (governmental law - zoning and land use case arising out of proposed quarry) • City of Knoxville v. The City of Knoxville Pension Board, et al., 2012 WL 6477024 (Dec. 14, 2012) (governmental law – dispute involving major employee pension benefits) • SNPCO v. City of Jefferson City, 363 S.W. 3d 467 (Tenn. 2012) (governmental law – land use dispute over sale of fireworks) • Phillips v. County of Anderson and City of Clinton, 2001 WL 456065 (April 2001) (governmental law – dispute concerning public financing with industrial bond issue) • Mars v. City of Clinton, 1994 WL 320398 (Tenn. Ct. App. July 07, 1994) (governmental law-inverse condemnation) • American Transit Corp. et al. v. Charles E. Cardwell, Commissioner of Revenue, State of Tennessee, 1991 WL 460 (Tenn. 1991) (governmental law – state use tax) • Knox County v. City of Knoxville, 786 S.W. 2d 936 (Tenn. 1990) (governmental law – school merger) ### Workers' Compensation • Lynch v. City of Jellico, 205 S.W. 3d 384 (Tenn. 2006) • Bohanon v. City of Knoxville, 136 S.W. 3d 621 (Tenn. 2004) • Scales v. City of Oak Ridge, 53 S.W. 3d 649 (Tenn. 2001) • Allen v. City of Gatlinburg, 36 S.W. 3d 73 (Tenn. 2001) --- ## Benjamin K. Lauderback URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/benjamin-k-lauderback/ #### Member # Benjamin K. Lauderback Email Benj Originally from Bristol, Tennessee, Benj practices law in Knoxville, Tennessee with his firm, Watson, Roach, Batson & Lauderback, PLC. He is licensed to practice in the State of Tennessee, the United States District Courts for both the Eastern and Middle Districts of Tennessee and the United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit. He has an active trial and courtroom practice having litigated numerous cases in state and federal courts throughout Tennessee since 2000. He has been involved in many appellate cases arguing before both the Federal Sixth Circuit and the State of Tennessee Court of Appeals. He is a current member of the Knoxville Bar Association and the Tennessee Bar Association. After attending and receiving his undergraduate degree from the University of Tennessee, Benj attended and earned his J.D. from the Nashville School of Law. He has practiced law for the past twenty-one years. Prior to that he worked as an insurance adjuster for four years. He serves as litigation counsel for multiple municipalities across Tennessee in both the trial attorney and consultant capacities. He has spoken as an invited participant at many conferences and seminars. He has participated in various panel discussions with members of the judiciary, other attorneys and other legal professionals. Benj’s areas of practice include law enforcement and governmental entity civil rights defense, employment defense, governmental and general tort liability defense, personal injury and the accompanying appellate work associated with those areas of practice. He is married and he and his wife, Christy, have four children. He spends as much of his off time as he can with them in the outdoors and coaching club soccer. ### Memberships • Knoxville Bar Association • Tennessee Bar Association ### Education • J.D., Nashville School of Law, Nashville, TN, 2000 • B.S., University of Tennessee, College of Communications, Knoxville, TN, 1995 ### Admissions • Tennessee, 2000 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 2002 • United States District Court, Middle District of Tennessee, 2004 • United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 2002 ## Representative Cases ##### Brumley v. City of Cleveland (2019) Obtained defense verdict after three day bench trial in employment discrimination matter involving whistleblower and retaliation claims. ##### Cooley v. E. Tennessee Human Res. Agency (2017) Appellate court affirmed grant of summary judgment in employment discrimination case by transit driver who failed fitness for duty evaluation that claimed disability discrimination and violations of the ADA and FMLA. ##### Stiles ex rel. D.S. v. Grainger Cty., Tenn (2016) Obtained favorable opinion in the Sixth Circuit in school bullying and education law matter. ##### Coffey v. City of Oak Ridge (2014) Prevailed in Tennessee Court of Appeals after a grant of summary judgment in an employment discrimination matter brought be a police officer alleging whisteblower retaliation and constructive discharge. --- ## Courtney Read Presents Training Seminar for Local Real Estate Agents URL: https://watsonroach.com/2022/05/11/courtney-read-presents-training-seminar-for-local-real-estate-agents/ Courtney Read recently presented a training seminar for real estate agents as to specific legal and ethical considerations that they are facing in today’s real estate market.   The presentation included discussion on multiple offer situations, escalation clauses, cash over appraisal, buyer lover letters, and issues surrounding home inspections. --- ## Insurance Defense URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/insurance-defense/ # Insurance Defense Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Handling litigation matters and advising insurance and claims professionals Watson Roach attorneys work regularly with various insurance companies across the Southeast in the investigation and defense of insurance claims. Attorneys at Watson Roach are experienced in direct representation of insurance companies in uninsured motorist matters, coverage litigation, bad faith claims, and alternative dispute resolution like mediation and arbitration. Watson Roach attorneys work closely with insurance professionals and adjusters in quickly evaluating claims, and determining how best to efficiently dispose of insurance claims while working to protect the interests of the individual insured. Where resolution is not possible, Watson Roach attorneys are prepared to litigate matters through trial. --- ## Robert H. Watson, Jr. URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/robert-h-watson-jr/ #### Attorney (1945-2014) # Robert H. Watson, Jr. Robert Watson graduated from Central High School and attended the University of Tennessee, graduating from the College of Law in 1970. Robert was a member of the Reserve Officer Training Corp. and he entered the Army in 1970 as a Second Lieutenant. He was honorably discharged from the Army Reserve with a rank of Captain. In 1970, Robert began his law practice as a staff attorney for the Legal Aid Clinic. He began private practice in 1972. In 1983, he formed the firm currently known as Watson, Roach, Batson and Lauderback, P.L.C. During his legal career, Robert represented governmental entities, individuals, and physicians throughout the State of Tennessee. He was Chief Trial Counsel for the Tennessee Municipal League Risk Management Pool for 20 years. For over 30 years, he represented the City of Knoxville and Knox County in a variety of litigation on behalf of the City, County, or their employees. Robert briefed and argued numerous cases in the Tennessee Court of Appeals, the Tennessee Supreme Court, and the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals. He was Chairman of the Advisory Board of the Lincoln Memorial University's Duncan School of Law and member of the Lincoln Memorial University Board of Trustees. He was involved in countless lawsuits in all state and federal courts in Tennessee. He was a trial lawyer and epitomizes what a trial lawyer is supposed to be. He was a "lawyer’s lawyer." Robert’s principals of vigorous, aggressive, and ethical advocacy continue to form the basis of Watson Roach’s approach to litigation. Robert lived life to the fullest. He loved his career, but was at heart a family man. His huge smile, generous spirit, and love of nature will be missed but not forgotten. --- ## Tennessee Supreme Court Limits Damages in Health Care Liability Case URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/06/25/tennessee-supreme-court-limits-damages-in-health-care-liability-case/ This month, the Tennessee Supreme Court addressed the applicability of Tennessee’s cap on noneconomic damages for an injured plaintiff and her spouse in Cynthia E. Yebuah, et al. v. Center for Urological Treatment, PLC . In this case, a patient had her kidney removed due to the discovery of a malignant mass in 2005. The patient had subsequent CT scans to monitor whether any abnormality reoccurred in her kidneys. Several years later, the patient consulted a gastroenterologist about abdominal pain. During a laparoscopic procedure, the gastroenterologist discovered a foreign object that was believed to have been left behind during her 2005 procedure. The patient and her husband filed a healthcare liability action in Davidson County against the surgeon who allegedly left the device in her abdomen, a radiologist who allegedly failed to discover and report the foreign object in a subsequent CT scan, and their employers. The doctors themselves were eventually voluntarily dismissed. The case proceeded to trial against their employers under a theory of vicarious liability. During trial, Radiology Alliance, P.C. received a directed verdict, which left the Center for Urological Treatment, PLC to face the jury alone. The jury awarded a total of $4,000,000.00 to the patient for pain, suffering and loss of enjoyment of life. The jury also awarded $500,000.00 to her husband for his loss of consortium claim. After considering the parties’ motions to alter or amend the judgment, the trial court determined that the statutory cap of $750,000 on noneconomic damages, as set out in Tenn. Code Ann. §29-39-102, should apply to each plaintiff’s damages separately. The trial court amended the judgment to a judgment in favor of the patient in the amount of $750,000.00 and a judgment to her husband of $500,000.00. The Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s decision. The Supreme Court determined that this was an issue of statutory construction of the non-economic damages caps in Tenn. Code Ann. §29-39-102. The Supreme Court determined that the phrase “each injured plaintiff” in the statute was not equivalent or interchangeable with “each plaintiff.” The Supreme Court recognized that a loss of consortium claim is a separate but derivative claim, such that recovery of damages for such a claim depends on whether the injured plaintiff prevails at trial. In light of the statutory cap on non-economic damages, the plaintiff patient and her plaintiff spouse’s damages are limited. It was the Court’s determination that the noneconomic damages of the injured patient plaintiff and her husband could not exceed $750,000.00 pursuant to Tenn. Code Ann. §29-39-102. This decision essentially holds that a single statutory cap on non-economic damages applies to an injured plaintiff and their spouse’s loss of consortium claim. --- ## Tippany P. Ward joins firm as Associate URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/02/08/tippany-p-ward-joins-firm-as-associate/ The firm is pleased to announce that Tippany P. Ward passed the Tennessee Bar Exam, was licensed to practice law in December 2020, and has joined us as an associate. A Knoxville native, Mrs. Ward earned her Bachelor’s degree and Doctor of Jurisprudence from University of Tennessee at Knoxville. She will practice in the areas of civil litigation, employment practices liability, professional liability, and governmental entity defense. --- ## Jon G. Roach, Of Counsel URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/jon-g-roach-of-counsel/ #### Of Counsel # Jon G. Roach, Of Counsel Email Jon Mr. Roach has served in multiple judicial and administrative positions in his career including as City Law Director for the City of Knoxville from 1976 to 1983, Special General Sessions Judge from 1974 to 1975, and Hearing Officer for the City of Knoxville Civil Service Merit Board from 2003 to the present. Mr. Roach devotes 75% of his practice to litigation. He has argued numerous cases at all levels of court proceedings from trial to the Tennessee Supreme Court. He is certified as a Civil Trial Specialist by both the National Board of Trial Advocacy and the Tennessee Commission on Continuing Legal Education and Specialization. Mr. Roach is also an Approved Rule 31 Certified Mediator with the Tennessee Supreme Court. ### Awards + Recognitions • AV® Preeminent Peer Review Rated by Martindale-Hubbell ### Education • J.D., University of Tennessee College of Law, Knoxville, TN, 1969 • B.S., University of Tennessee, Business Administration, Knoxville, TN, 1967 ### Admissions • Tennessee, 1970 • United States District Court, Eastern District of Tennessee, 1970 • United States District Court, Middle District of Tennessee, 1993 • United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit, 1981 • United States Tax Court, 1970 • United States Court of Federal Claims, 1970 • United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, 1983 • Supreme Court of the United States, 1973 --- ## Governmental Entity Defense URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/governmental-entity-defense/ # Governmental Entity Defense Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Experts in public entity risk and constitutional litigation Cities, counties, law enforcement agencies, boards of education, and other municipal agencies are aggressively defended. The firm has a long history of representing governmental entities in matters ranging from routine slip and falls to high profile claims alleging police misconduct. --- ## Courtney Read Elected Fellow of the Knoxville Bar Foundation URL: https://watsonroach.com/2023/07/12/courtney-read-elected-fellow-of-the-knoxville-bar-foundation/ Member Courtney Read was chosen as one of the 2023 class of Fellows of the Knoxville Bar Foundation and was recognized at the Foundation’s 2023 annual reception. The Knoxville Bar Foundation is a not-for-profit foundation established to improve public awareness of the legal system in Knoxville, the administration of justice and the delivery of legal services through the distribution of its funds. Each year the Foundation inducts a new Fellows Class which is less than one percent of the active bar association. The Fellows represent quality men and women practitioners in our community who have distinguished themselves in the practice of law and service. The Foundation's Board of Directors reviews numerous nominations and determines the inductees who have demonstrated superior legal skills and high ethical standards and service to the community. --- ## Professional Liability URL: https://watsonroach.com/practice-areas/professional-liability/ # Professional Liability Watson Roach has nearly 200 years of combined experience in litigation to help get you the best results for your case. #### Watson Roach ## Helping the professionals that help others Watson Roach is experienced in defending real estate agents, surveyors and related professionals in errors and omissions (E&O) disputes ranging from simple negligence to complex claims for violations of federal or state statutes. Clients are defended before professional licensing boards and regulatory agencies. --- ## Dan R. Pilkington and Emily Taylor Obtain Unanimous Jury Verdict in Federal Civil Rights Trial URL: https://watsonroach.com/2022/06/06/dan-r-pilkington-and-emily-taylor-obtain-unanimous-jury-verdict-in-federal-civil-rights-trial/ A Federal jury took less than two hours to return a verdict in favor of the firm’s client, a local municipality, in a Section 1983 civil rights trial alleging violations of the First Amendment. Firm members Dan R. Pilkington and Emily Taylor represented the defendant municipality. The lawsuit alleged that the City retaliated against the Plaintiffs for their speech and conduct protected by the First Amendment. After a multi-day trial, the jury found that the Plaintiffs’ allegations were unfounded and entered a unanimous decision in favor of the municipality. The firm commends Dan and Emily for their professionalism and hard work. Watson, Roach, Batson & Lauderback is committed to providing superior service and representation to all of our clients. --- ## Dan R. Pilkington Provides Training to Local Law Enforcement URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/01/22/dan-r-pilkington-provides-training-to-local-law-enforcement/ Dan R. Pilkington assisted local law enforcement officers by providing training on use of force and other constitutional claims as part of a course of Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) training in March. CIT is a first-responder model of police-based crisis intervention with community, health care and advocacy partnerships. CIT provides 40 hours of specialized training for problem solving and de-escalating crisis situations with individuals who have a mental illness. The training complies with the requirements of the Tennessee Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission (P.O.S.T.), which serves as the primary regulatory body for Tennessee law enforcement. --- ## Emily Taylor and Courtney Read Provide Training to Municipal Risk Managers URL: https://watsonroach.com/2023/04/17/emily-taylor-and-courtney-read-provide-training-to-municipal-risk-managers/ Emily Taylor and Courtney Read presented to municipal risk managers at the 2023 Tennessee PRIMA conference on March 17, 2023. Ms. Taylor and Ms. Read discussed important steps and provided practical tips in conducting pre-suit investigations for a variety of claims that municipalities face. --- ## Elise M. DeNicola URL: https://watsonroach.com/our-attorneys/elise-m-denicola/ #### Associate # Elise M. DeNicola Email Elise Elise DeNicola, a Knoxville native, is an associate attorney at Watson, Roach, Batson & Lauderback, P.L.C. Having earned both her bachelor’s degree and J.D. from the University of Tennessee, Elise has strong ties to the local community and is proud to build her career in her hometown. While attending the University of Tennessee College of Law, Elise was actively involved in student leadership, serving as a member of both the Student Bar Association and the Student Conduct Board. Throughout law school, her coursework focused on healthcare law, preparing her to navigate the complex legal issues that impact the healthcare industry. Elise first joined Watson Roach as a law clerk during her final year of law school, gaining invaluable hands-on experience and insight into the firm’s approach to legal practice. This experience has aided her in her transition into an associate attorney role. Outside the office, Elise enjoys spending time with her family and her chocolate lab, Milo. She also loves playing the piano and can often be found on the tennis court or the golf course. ### Memberships • Knoxville Bar Association • Tennessee Bar Association ### Education • J.D., University of Tennessee College of Law, Knoxville, TN, 2024 • B.A., summa cum laude, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN, 2022 ### Admissions • Tennessee, 2024 --- ## Hanson Tipton Completes Service as KBA President URL: https://watsonroach.com/2021/04/01/hanson-tipton-completes-service-as-kba-president/ On December 11, 2020, Hanson Tipton completed his year of service as President of the Knoxville Bar Association and will continue to serve on the Knoxville Bar Association Board of Governors as Immediate Past President during 2021. Mr. Tipton served as KBA President during extraordinary times and shepherded the KBA’s transition to largely virtual operations for board and committee meetings along with the transition of many of the KBA’s flagship events into a virtual format. The firm congratulates Mr. Tipton on his year of service to the local bar. ---